PORTRAIT OF A COFFEE HOUSE: People engage in conversation, for it is there that news is communicated and where those interested in politics criticize the government in all freedom and without being fearful, since the government does not heed what the people say. {Jean Chardin, 17th Century French Traveller}
Showing posts with label Civil Liberties. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Civil Liberties. Show all posts

06 February 2012

A letter from Syria to the World

A very moving letter being shared via Facebook from Syria to the world:
Letter from Khaled Khalifa to his friends around of the world 
My friends, writers and journalists from all over the world, in China and Russia, I would like to inform you that my people is being subjected to a genocide. 
A week ago the forces of the Syrian regime stepped up its attacks on the rebellious cities, especially in the cities of Homs, Zabadani, the suburbs of Damascus, Rastan, Madaya, Wadi Barada, Figeh, Idlib and villages of the Zawiya mountain. In the past week, up until the moment in which I am writing these lines, more than a thousand martyrs fell, many of them children, and hundreds of homes were destroyed on top of their inhabitants. 
The world's blindness encouraged the regime's attempt to eliminate the peaceful revolution in Syria, with an unrivaled repressive force. The support of Russia, China, Iran and the silence of the world in the face of the crimes committed in broad daylight, has allowed the regime's killing of my people for the past eleven months. But in the last week, since February 2cd, the features of the massacre were made clear. The scene of hundreds of thousands of Syrians who took to the streets of their towns and villages on the night of the massacre of Khalidiya, the night of last Friday to Saturday, raising their hands in prayer and in tears, is heart breaking and puts the humanitarian tragedy of Syria in the center of the world. It is a clear expression of our feeling of orphanhood, resulting from our abandonment by the world, which is content by political and economic sanctions that do not stop murderers or restrain blood bathed tanks.  
My people who faced death with bear chests and songs is being, in these very moments, subjected to a cleansing campaign. Our rebellious cities face sieges unprecedented in the history of world revolutions, preventing medical personnel to attend to the wounded, as field hospitals are being bombed in cold blood and destroyed. The entry of relief organizations is also prevented, phone lines are cut, and food and medicine are blocked to the extent that the smuggling of blood bags or Satamol tablets into the affected areas is considered a crime worthy of imprisonment in detention camps, the details of which will shock you one day.
In its modern history, the world has not yet seen valor and courage such as those displayed by the revolutionary Syrians in all our towns and villages, as the world has not yet seen such a silence, that is now considered a complicity in the murder and extermination of my people. 
My people is the people of peace, coffee and music, that I wish you will taste one day, roses the fragrances of which I hope you will breathe one day, so that you know that the center of the world is today exposed to a genocide, and that the whole world is an accomplice to the spilling of our blood. 
I can not say more in these difficult moments, but I hope you will take action in solidarity with my people, through whatever means you deem appropriate. I know that writing stands helpless and naked in front of the Russian guns, tanks and missiles bombing cities and civilians, but I have no wish for your silence to be an accomplice of the killings as well. 
Khaled Khalifa
Damascus, Syria

29 September 2011

BBC Panorama: Syria Inside the Secret Revolution

Apologies for being MIA. Have been taking on a few projects these past few weeks and life has been a little hectic. Need to catch up with news and reading!

This BBC report is brought to you via The Revolting Syrian:

06 July 2011

Zero Silence: a documentary about the free wor(l)d

Zero Silence is an amazing project in-the-making, a documentary about the political impact of the Internet and non-traditional media in the Arab World. Click on the hyperlink above for more details on the project! You can also 'Like' their Facebook page here to keep up with news on the upcoming documentary.


24 June 2011

Silenced: the choice between dissidence or living a 'normal' life

Here's a thought worth reflecting on: if you had the choice to make a decent wage, live a 'normal' untroubled life in exchange for silence and lack of political expression, would you do it? Is it worth fighting for a cause if it means the end of your livelihood, the harassment and blackmail of your family members, possible detention, torture, or even your death? This is the choice many people face every day living under repressive regimes and many choose the security of a maintaining a 'normal' life to openly challenging government malpractices, abuses, and corruption.

The New York Times published two stories recently illustrative of the costs of the choices dissidents face. In one story Azeri blogger and opposition activist Emin Milli was freed from prison only to find that his entire life had been robbed from him. Those who feared government retaliation for association to Milli cut off ties with anyone remotely linked with him. "His wife’s father had been fired from his government job because of Mr. Milli’s political activities. His own father had died while he was in prison. His wife, her own future in turmoil, had asked for a divorce. Mr. Milli spent much of this spring in his apartment, free time gaping before him like a chasm." More recently, the release of Chinese artist Ai Wei Wei appears to be a victory, however, the New York Times added that the artist has since "muzzled" himself. The New York Times quoted Nicholas Bequelin, a Human Rights Watch researcher in Hong Kong, as noting that the artist “has a Damocles sword hanging over his head. That means any time he opens his mouth, he puts himself in danger.”

Given the costs of challenging a repressive and corrupt government one would have to weigh when the benefits of posing a public challenge to the status quo outweighs the costs. Everyday, opposition activists, bloggers, and other dissidents in countries with limited freedoms are detained or killed with little outside support and only with a few international NGOs advocating campaigns on their behalf. Burma has a particularly nasty track record on the index of civil liberties according to Freedom House, garnering one of the worse ratings for freedom by the rights' organisation. More recently, in Syria and Bahrain, arbitrary detentions and torture of suspected opposition activists and their associates have become the norm. Yet the mass movements in the Arab world sparked in Tunisia has resulted in a change of popular consciousness whereby people realize that collectively by casting off fear they have power to cast off bad governments, revolution.

In countries where governments create an atmosphere of public fear through secret police mechanisms, arbitrary arrests and the threat of detainment or violence, individuals are careful not to challenge their governments because they don't know whether their neighbors are informants who would turn them in for dissent. On the flip side, what individuals living in such an atmosphere probably don't realize is that many of their neighbors are probably as equally dissatisfied with the current political state of affairs as they are but given that no one voices it that status quo prevails. Furthermore, repressive governments are usually quick to make examples of individual dissidents as seen in the case of Milli and Ai Wei Wei. Dissidents and opposition activists only have force if they're popularly backed, but this requires collective courage from an entire population and the willingness of individuals to put their neck on the line or an individual with such powerful charisma he or she inspires collective action. Such movements are not always successful as seen from the 2007 anti-government protests in Burma, the so-called 'Saffron Revolution' which ended with the military junta willing to talk to the opposition but unwilling to cede any power. A pyrrhic victory. More recently, Libya portrays the potentially heavy costs of challenging a dictator, all out bloody civil war.

We hail individual courage and martyrdom for a cause. In Burma, Aung San Suu Kyi has become an international hero for wanting to bring democracy to her country and having paid the price with nearly 15 years of house arrest until her release in 2010. The more iconic image of Buddhist monk, Thích Quảng Đức, committing an act of self-immolation in protest of the persecution of Buddhist monks in Vietnam back in the 1960s is also very telling of the sympathy popular consciousness has for those dying for an idea, a human sacrifice in the name of protest. The public reveres those who can and will sacrifice their lives and livelihood if it means saying 'No' to a system which does not acknowledge the uniqueness of human individuality and giving us a life worth living.  It is the choice of defining what type of life is worth living and what gives us meaning through the recreation of our political systems and the right to express our beliefs openly.

Not everyone is willing to take the risks. When the choice is between your life, the life of your family and friends, keeping the roof over your head and having the job which will feed your children, most of us would pick survival over challenging a repressive regime or they would challenge the status quo but only from the apparent safety of exile. The question all dissidents must ask themselves is if what they believe in is worth the costs and, if it is, whether they have the courage, tenacity, and creativity to inspire others to join them.

05 May 2011

Thrashing Media Freedoms & Arbitrary Arrests: Eye on Syria and Bahrain

The Trump v. Obama bonanza and the recent death of Osama bin Laden (carefully timed to be announced in the middle of The Apprentice) has been drowning out a lot of more important ongoing news. World Press Freedom Day has gone by this May 3rd and, lest we forget, journalists in Syria and Bahrain are facing rough odds. Paris-based Reporters Without Borders issued this year's list of press freedom "predators" this past Tuesday. Who's new to the list this year? The King of Bahrain.

Yesterday, Toby C. Jones published a great piece on the Arab Reform Bulletin, a publication by the Carnegie Endowment for Peace, with an analysis and overview of Bahrain's censorship measures. To name a few, Al Wasat, Bahrain's leading independent paper is expected to close down on May 10 and, according to The Media Line, "the Bahrain Center for Human Rights reported on Tuesday that 68 journalists have been laid-off, arrested and threatened." Even medical personnel and staff are not immune to the repression. The Guardian reported that medics have become targets of retribution simply for helping injured protesters. The Media Line further added that about 50 medics would face military trial for 'subversive acts.'

In Syria, a similar pattern of response against media and opposition supporters has taken place. This past Wednesday, Al Jazeera confirmed that one of its journalists, Dorothy Parvaz, was arrested in Syria. Al Jazeera has launched an online campaign on Twitter with the tag #FreeDorothy as well as a Facebook page. Today, the Neiman Foundation, of which Parvaz is a fellow, has also called for her release. For the past month, arbitrary arrests of journalists and suspected opposition supporters has been the norm in Syria with the addition of violent crackdowns against protesters, especially in Deraa, which some observers are calling a 'massacre.'

If these regimes believe that arbitrary arrests, violent retribution, and thrashing media freedoms will maintain the status quo they really ought to reconsider their tactics. Historically, such actions only result in strengthening the resolve of those who genuinely seek political reform for their countries building up international criticism for the regime and sympathy for the victims of crackdowns. Is there any political sense in detaining journalists, bloggers and medics, shooting at unarmed protesters, and even using torture and blackmail to threaten opposition supporters? Do these tactics ever provide a desired outcome in long-run? While in the private sphere individuals are expected to act with civility towards one another, the same ethics and rules of behavior never apply in the political realm which is a sad sight. If the governments of Syria and Bahrain continue to take "desperate" measures against protesters and media representatives they will surely find themselves committing political suicide.

09 April 2011

Story Highlights: Anti-Corruption Warriors & More Blogger Arrests

Really loving some of the investigative pieces The New Yorker has come out with this month:

A Murder Foretold: The story of the murder of lawyer Rodrigo Rosenberg who fought against Guatemalan corruption and violence. Rosenberg was murdered while hotly pursuing justice for the violent murder case of Lebanese businessman, Khalil Musa. Upon his death he left a video recording with a former spy chief accusing the Guatemalan President and his wife for the murders of Musa and himself. The video was posted on YouTube and tweeted resulting in public protests and launching a major investigation by the International Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala (CICIG) Absolutely riveting.

Net Impact: The story of Alexey Navalny, lawyer and blogger, who is fighting Russia's government corruption head on through his blog RosPil which utilizes the Russian public examine documents and to call out dodgy business deals and government tenders.

Recent news clippings of interest:

UAE blogger who called for reform taken from his apartment - CNN reported that Ahmed Mansoor was abducted from his apartment by 10 men who also confiscated his lap top and his passport.

Egypt blogger arrests set "dangerous precedent" - Reuters reported that Maikel Nabil was arrested for "insulting the military" and faces three years in prison.

'Jasmine' Blogger Arrested - The Standard reported the arrest of writer and blogger Ran Yunfei for challenging the Communist Party.

05 April 2011

Crowd Intelligence: The Case for Supporting a Free Web Globally

In a previous post regarding civil liberties, I mentioned that philosophically one could argue that total freedom of information could reasonably be dangerous to society especially in democracies where lines can be blurred between what constitutes a criminal action versus what is simply freedom of expression (the ambiguous term 'terrorist' being one such issue). Although, I suggested we should look at what actions constitute the intent to actually harm or impede on the rights of others versus actions that promote public accountability of one's government policies.

Currently, in Bahrain where protests are ongoing, the government has violently cracked down on opposition supporters and the media. The Bahrain Human Rights Council claims that 370 people have been arrested since the imposition of the emergency law on March 15. These include bloggers, human rights activists, and journalists. On March 28, the military public prosecutor imposed a media gag, banning "any publishing, through print, audio, video and online media, based on the requirements of discretion and commitment to the principle of confidential investigation." Here we have a government which instead of empowering and serving its people seeks to serve its own selfish interests by suppressing them. This is an unwise policy that is likely to backlash in the long-run. Moral realism and political karma will eventually prevail. No government can succeed or have stability for the long-term without seeking to serve the population on which its legitimacy depends, whether it's a monarchy, an oligarchy, or a democracy.

Consider this, right now the Internet is not a free medium globally. Censorship imposition and information regulation varies in different countries and government monitoring is quite common. I am not against monitoring the web if it is to prevent crime with proper privacy laws in place to protect innocent individuals. However, if monitoring is utilized to root out, blackmail, arrest, or even kill political opposition leaders such technology should not be sold by democratic countries to non-democratic ones. 

A free web benefits everyone politically, socially, and culturally because it empowers individuals. If people globally were to have open access to information, without political censorship, exchange ideas, have public forums of free debate then collectively the Internet becomes a powerful catalyst to transform societies simply by granting individuals the responsibility to verify fact from fiction and to organize collective decision-making in keeping their own governments accountable. Of course this depends on a population that has access to the Internet and who are literate, something that should be encouraged and promoted. Above all, greater civil liberties on the Internet also means inspiring greater creativity in individuals through collective exchange. This has massive impact not merely among artistic and literary groups, but also among corporate, business, and civil society groups who can connect through the Internet. Problems that have gone unresolved through isolated decision-making can benefit by access to crowd intelligence.

In 2004, James Surowiecki published a fascinating book The Wisdom of Crowds. Surowiecki argues that  the aggregation of information in groups results in decisions that are often better made than any single individual in the group. He argues that four elements are necessary for a 'wise crowd': 1. diversity of opinion, 2. independence of opinion (i.e. one's opinion is not influenced by others), 3. decentralization (i.e. people can draw from their unique local knowledge), and 4. aggregation (i.e. mechanisms are in place to turn private judgments into a collective decision). 

In corporate cultures, even among NGOs and in government departments, decision-making can be easily isolated, 'cliquefied', and threatened by the possibility of group-think. Surowiecki addresses the cases where crowd intelligence has failed: where opinions in a group are homogenous rather than diverse, where hierarchies are too strict, where groups are protective of their 'turf' or specialization and don't allow outsiders to contribute, where decisions are imitated, and where emotionalism or herd instinct can take hold. 

Now consider the massive resource potential of collective intelligence the Internet provides if it were a free medium globally. People across the world could easily provide for at least three of Surowieki's conditions for a 'wise crowd.' Already, mediums such as Wikipedia and Twitter allow people to cross reference information, cite sources, share news and opinion, and debate dubious points. Twitter and Facebook have been cited as factors helping aid the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia. Although their influence has been questioned in regards to the current Arab revolutions taking place, one can't underestimate them as powerful tools or organization or to rally public opinion among a younger generation of net users.

Governments do themselves a disservice through the imposition of censorship and fail to tap a significant resource when they limit forums of information exchange. What if these online crowds were properly utilized to resolve major political, social, and economic problems globally instead of relying solely on 'experts'? The possibilities the Internet provides for this is endless. A politically uncensored Internet globally could well transcend language barriers and provide for collective creativity and problem-solving as well as for social, cultural, and political transformation. 

31 March 2011

Threatened, Missing or Arrested Bloggers: Submit a Report

Global Voices Advocacy hosts a page keeping track of the status of bloggers around the world who have gone missing or have been arrested and follows-up on them. Their project, Threatened Voices, tracks the suppression of online free speech.

Lend your support to these bloggers here. If you have any information on their whereabouts and status please contact the Threatened Voices project by either leaving a comment on the specific blogger's page or submitting a report regarding any bloggers you know who have been threatened, gone missing, or have been arrested or whether they have been released.

30 March 2011

Who Profits from Censorship? Timothy Karr Tells All

Back in 2004, when I was still a student at a private university in Washington, I was appalled to discover that the company who regulated my university networks, Cisco, also sold products that allowed the Chinese government to censor websites and regulate information access. Cisco is not the only company profiting from authoritarian regimes. Timothy Karr, the campaign director for Save The Internet as well as a contributer to The Huffington Post, has written extensively on US companies aiding and abetting censorship overseas. One of his recent reports, "Censorship: Made In the USA" is a damning indictment of American companies supporting the crackdown of Arab bloggers and newsreaders simply by doing business with regimes not particularly for civil liberties.

Karr cites a new report published by the OpenNet Initiative, an NGO advocating for an Open Internet. The report lists several US companies who have sold technologies that red list or block access to websites to oppressive governments. These include the popular McAffee, Inc., Websence, Inc., and Palo Alto Network.  Previously, Karr had published a story concerning another US company, Narus, "which sold to Egypt and Libya an Internet spying technology that lets state security forces track online and cellphone communications and even target the speaker's whereabouts for arrest." This story kicked off an investigation by the House Foreign Relations Committee and the State Department. Karr writes that the results of these investigations are still pending.

According to Karr, Rep. Bill Keating (MA) is the only voice on Capital Hill promising to propose legislation that would prevent US companies from selling censorship technology. Karr has posted a link to a petition to both Rep. Keating and Sen. Dick Durbin (IL) to get this legislation moving forward. Of course, despite citizen action I have my reservations that these measures will succeed. One could say, the United States has a political interest in promoting free media, but on the other hand it depends.

This is not the first time American companies have committed abuses overseas where the interests of capitalism take precedence over liberal ideals. The logic these companies operate on is that simply because they sold the perpetrators the tools of the crime leaves them innocent of the crime because they're just doing business and are not responsible for the purposes for which their products are used. This logic is flawed because in the long-run these companies will suffer 'moral costs' of their amoral investments. Here moral realism can be applied: public opinion will ultimately tarnish the reputation of these companies and when the political status quo is overturned in countries where oppression has been the norm (as currently seen in the Middle East) they will lose their business. Companies can't continue doing business this way and profit in the long-term without considering the people they're exploiting and how that will effect their markets and image in the future. It's simply bad business. Short-term profits won't compensate for long-term losses.

On the bright side, however, some American companies understand the concept above and have taken steps to do business by promoting civil liberties. In 2009, Google faced-off with China over censorship barriers and had its license to operate in China revoked. Google has since renewed its license with China without making concessions to censorship. Moreover, Google is crafting and seeking influence Internet policy by supporting an open and free Internet. If other US companies followed Google's business model, conducting their business practices to empower people with their services and products instead of repressing them, they would be creating greater opportunity and profiting themselves by the very act of profiting others.

Update: A really fascinating story on Google just came out in which the Internet giant is investing $1 million on Internet censorship detection technologies. Go Google!!!

________________________

Timothy Karr also runs a popular blog, MediaCitizen (http://mediacitizen.blogspot.com/), covering issues as far ranging as criticism of media policy, censorship, analysis on old media and new media.

29 March 2011

Crackdowns on Bloggers & Journalists Amidst Protests

Syrian blogger Ahmed Abu Al Khair (http://ahmadblogs.net/) has been arrested in Syria earlier last week. Global Voices Advocacy contributer, Anas Qtiesh, reported that Ahmed was previously arrested in February and has been subsequently re-arrested amidst protests in Daraa last week. Qtiesh also reports that journalist, Khaled Elekhtyar has gone missing.

To read the full story and support these individuals please click here.

Al Jazeera has also covered the status of Arab bloggers amid crackdowns here.

Update: It appears that one of Bahrain's most influential bloggers, Mahmood Al-Yousif (http://mahmood.tv/), has also been arrested last night.

Rape as a Weapon of War: Women Fight Back in Libya

A terrible story came out of Libya earlier last week of a woman who was raped by government troops in Libya. Iman al-Obeidi, however, would not be silenced by shame. She stormed into a hotel in Tripoli where foreign journalists were based to openly disclose her identity and tell her story. Government minders in the hotel started a brawl with her as foreign journalists sought to protect her. She loudly declared that she had been detained at a check point, tied up, abused, and gang raped.  Hadeel Al-Shalchi of the Associated Press reported: "The woman, who appeared in her 30's, wore a black robe and a floral scarf around her neck and identified herself. She had scratches on her face and she pulled up her black robe to reveal a bloodied thigh. She said neighbors in the area where she was detained helped her escape."

At the end of the scuffle however, al-Obeidi was dragged out by the government minders who then came back and claimed to the journalists that she was drunk and mentally ill. These comments were later retracted and a government spokesman claimed it was a case of rape and it was being investigated and that al-Obeidi was "safe and well." A recent follow-up to the story by Al Jazeera today noted that al-Obeidi was still missing that that government officials were trying to bribe her family with large sums of money to convince their daughter recant the story. Her mother declared publicly that she told her daughter to "keep silent" (in regards to recanting), and her family had noted that she had been targeted after she had participated in a pro-democracy protest. Furthermore, while government spokesmen declared to journalists that al-Obeidi was a "prostitute," her family furnished Al Jazeera with photos of her receiving her law degree.

Al Jazeera reported: "Iman is rapidly become a cause célèbre in Libya. Highly unusual in a culture that traditionally secludes its women and exercises a code of honor."Moreover, the Al Jazeera reporter noted that "other women" had been detained along with al-Obeidi and their status is unknown. 

Libyan state TV, predictably, has not been kind to al-Obeidi. A friend shared with me the following link to a state TV response to the rape story. The newscaster had the gall to declare: ‎"From a psychological perspective, we know that any woman who has gone through any kind of rape it's impossible that she would have acted like this woman right after being raped" and claimed she had received this opinion from "doctors." Furthermore, today Libyan state TV aired what the claimed was 'secret footage' of al-Obeidi being interviewed by officials which appears to be some actress with her face covered up in al-Obeidi's scarf. 

Iman al-Obeidi's case is a reflection of a larger issue that often occurs in war - rape used as a weapon against women. This is not unique to Libya although certainly in a culture where rape victims shrink back in shame and silence, al-Obeidi's courage is astounding, more so in front of pro-Gaddafi minders and international journalists. She gives a voice to rape victims who have otherwise chosen to remain silent. Al Jazeera reporters talking to doctors in Libya discovered that Gaddafi soldiers had "condoms and viagra" in their pockets suggesting that they were intending to rape women on rebel territory. Doctors also noted that they were treating rape victims. 

Of course, the drama is just unfolding. In a diabolical twist, today, The New York Daily News just reported that al-Obeidi is to face criminal charges for slander, her accusations a "grave offense" to the 15 men whom she claims raped her.  British-based Telegraph further detailed that a Libyan government spokesman stated, "The boys accused of doing this are furious. They want to kill her. They have filed a case to defend their family name. In our culture these are very serious charges that will last for generations." The Libyan government response is stupefying. To blame the victim as a perpetrator against national honor after she faced horrific trauma at the hands of Gaddafi troops is appalling. There is no honor in raping and abusing a woman.

Bourzou Daragahi, writing on the LA Times Blog, stated, "Human Rights Watch, a New York-based advocacy group that has been trying unsuccessfully to gain access to Libya, demanded that her family and international media be allowed to independently verify the official claim that she is free and safe." He also added: "Sarah Leah Whitson, director of the Middle East and North Africa division of the rights group, said that 'Libya has a history of mistreating women who have been raped or sexually abused and often jails them for what it describes as their own protection. Libyan judges also have an unfortunate practice of arranging for rapists to marry their victim, with the consent of her family, to 'save' her from ... an otherwise tainted future,' Whitson said in an email. 'The marriage also allows the rapist to avoid jail time.'" 

Libyan women have come out onto the streets to rally in support of al-Obeidi and her family has taken a decidedly non-traditional stance in publicly supporting their daughter and seeking her release. It will be a matter of time before we find out what's become of her and the other women that have been detained with her. 

21 March 2011

The Cyber War Against Political Oppression & Censorship

In good news, Al Jazeera English reported this past January that Slim Amamou, a Tunisian blogger, was appointed Minister for Youth and Sport in the new Tunisian government. Under the censorship strictures of ex-dictator's Ben Ali's regime, Amamou was an active blogger and a CEO of a Tunisian web development company. According to Al Jazeera, he and several other Tunisian bloggers were circulating news and videos supporting protests in opposition to Ben Ali's government. Their Facebook passwords were hacked, accounts deleted and Amamou, along with another Tunisian blogger, were subsequently arrested and later released with Ben Ali's disgraceful exit from Tunisia.

Although the Internet has brought a tremendous amount of opportunity for the exchange of news, views, and ideas on a global scale it has also proven to be politically ambiguous territory and a more contentious ground for political battles especially in oppressive countries where individual bloggers are transforming into revolutionaries. Bloggers have proven to be a potent political force in countries with stringent censorship policies and state-run media, so much so that they are subject to arrest, threats on their lives, and torture. Amamou is not the first blogger to be arrested in consequence of writing or spreading information criticizing government actions or rallying support for protests. In June 2008, The Guardian reported that that record numbers of bloggers had been arrested by repressive governments, such as China, Burma, Iran and Mubarak-ruled Egypt at the time.

More recently, several Syrian bloggers have been arrested or reported missing in light of the uprisings and protests taking place in the Middle East. They have proven to be courageous and outspoken. According to the International Freedom of Expression Exchange (IFEX) cited in the last link above, one Syrian blogger, 28 year-old Hadifa (http://ahmadblogs.net/) "appealed... for support for recently detained bloggers and for political prisoners in the Golan Heights (a region that Israel occupied in 1967 and annexed in 1981). He had also posted demands to the Syrian authorities, comments about the recent uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt, and advice on how to circumvent online censorship." The Daily Star also recently reported Lebanese bloggers were subjected to unprecedented crackdowns in 2010. In China, blogger and Guardian contributer, Ran Yunfei, has been arrested on the charge of 'subverting state power.'

Author Robert Greene wrote a particularly timely essay on his blog, The Descent of Power: An Interpretation of the Global Economic Crisis. His essay emphasizes that the Information revolution with the advent of the Internet and its ensuing social networks, forums, and news sharing platforms is devolving traditional centers of power by placing information access into the hands of individuals and in the process empowering them politically. A few relevant excerpts from his essay:
"In anthropology there is a concept known as historic fatality. What this means is that occasionally there emerges a certain idea, a certain way of doing things that is so immensely seductive to human beings that eventually it spreads around the globe and forever changes our way of life... We can make three generalizations at this point. When a group of people is given power, it forms a power center. This means, for instance, that a team of military leaders tends to think in two directions–how to promote the interests of the ruler, while also advancing its own agenda. Things now become political, as their interests will clash with other power centers. The ruler must now manage this growing complexity. The power environment becomes increasingly dangerous. 
Second, once people have been given power on this level, they do not want to give it back or return to an older way of governing. They work to keep what they have and extend their power base. And finally, once power becomes diluted and divided this way, it tends to keep on dividing, like a split atom. More and more people must be brought in to keep the whole functioning. And so over the course of centuries, power slowly became less and less concentrated... To a lesser degree we could talk of modern media as another power center that came to prominence in the 20th century, which in turn acted to dissolve and dilute previous concentrations of influence... Of course there remain concentrations of power and wealth in the world today. But on the other hand, there is no denying the remarkable evolution and dilution of power from that time millennia ago when it was mostly in the hands of one man. 
From this position in the present we can project into the future a period of even greater dilution, as more and more people around the globe feel the right and necessity to have more control over their lives... What interests me here is not the technology, but how it changes our relationship to power and authority, altering in so many ways the social dynamic–how people interact with one another. In this instance, the Internet is flattening out relationships that were once hierarchical and funneled through various centers. This tends to eat away at the prestige and authority of traditional sources of information such as newspapers, or expert opinions. It calls into question the need for so many middlemen in the world, and reveals the dubious source of their power."
The Internet is one of those historic fatalities. Individuals no longer have to go through media "middleman" to get their information and therefore politically bias media bureaus and state-run media are no longer the primary source of information. Moreover, younger generations who have been educated outside their countries are more tech savvy and more likely to figure out ways around government censorship programming and firewalls. In the long run, that means even the most oppressive governments will be unable to control the access individuals have to information. Bloggers, "twitterers", Googlers, and Facebookers all now hold a stake on information - its sourcing, framing, and dissemination - and they have power. This makes the Internet a space of serious political impact and influence and that means that the war against political oppression is not just on the streets in protest but in the cyber sphere against censorship.

It will be interesting to see how the cyber war will develop over time in the century and who will ultimately win. It is not just the philosophical and legal ramifications of freedom of information which must be considered but also the political empowerment of individuals in the face of traditional pillars of information control, namely governments and big corporate media outlets.
___________

Please visit the Committee to Protect Bloggers and the Committee to Protect Journalists to see what you can do to support politically dissenting bloggers around the world. 

18 March 2011

Daniel Ellsberg Defends Wikileaks

A really interesting interview with Daniel Ellsberg, the man who leaked the Pentagon Papers, by Anti-War Radio. You can listen to the interview on the link provided above or read the transcript on the same page. Ellsberg defends Julian Assange and Bradley Manning, a US soldier accused of leaking war documents to Wikileaks and who is currently in prison.

An excerpt of Ellsberg's take on the Wikileaks drama:
"To say that Julian Assange is guilty of treason has some problems since he’s an Australian citizen. But anyway, I was called a traitor, which was no more true of me than it is to say Bradley Manning, who is accused now of leaking, sitting in a jail in Quantico – he’s no more a traitor than I am, and I’m not. Neither of them are terrorists any more than I am, and I’m not. 
So I did get these comments. I didn’t get the “terrorist” at the time, because that wasn’t in vogue as a demonizing label then 40 years ago, but I would be called a terrorist now. I have no doubt at all, if I put out the same documents now, they would call me a terrorist, because that’s the bad thing now. 
Now, more than that, of course, I was – they’re searching now for a law with which to indict Assange for what he did, and of course Assange’s role is that essentially of the New York Times in the case of the Pentagon Papers or of WikiLeaks. There really is no basis in law that they’re going to find that can nail or can entrap or indict Assange that doesn’t apply to the New York Times exactly as well, since they have put out these clearly classified documents to the public.  
In fact, they’ve made the choice, along with the other four newspapers, Le Monde, Der Spiegel, The Guardian, and El Pais in Spain – they made the choice so far which documents in this Cablegate series to put out. Assange has put out on his own website essentially only those, with a few exceptions, but almost entirely those that have been chosen to be referred to or put out by these mainstream newspapers. 
So there is no judicial basis, no legal basis, for charging Assange with anything that doesn’t apply equally well to the New York Times, and it’s clear that the administration is not anxious to get in a legal fight with the New York Times. So they’re trying to distinguish Assange not only from me and the Pentagon Papers, but from the New York Times, and that’s really pretty impossible to do."

02 February 2011

Mubarak has shown his true colors...

...and the Egyptian army has shown whose side they're on. After spending a week remaining essentially neutral and seeming to befriend the anti-Mubarak protesters, last night, the Egyptian army allowed pro-Mubarak supporters into Tahrir Square and according to one source the military "blocked the anti-Mubarak [protesters] from exiting." Additionally, pro-Mubarak thugs armed with machetes and other weapons also inflitrated the square. Official estimates suggest that one soldier was killed and over 400 injured. [Update: According to Al Jazeera medical sources, as of midnight in Cairo, 2000+ have been reported injured in clashes.]

The possibility exists that the army may be working with Mubarak by creating disorder on purpose to claim it has legitimate right to later crack down on the civilian population to restore order. If that's the case, we could be seeing a massacre later on. I pray that's not the case and that the army remains neutral but that may be wholly wishful thinking.

Earlier today, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs took some questions where answers were decidedly shallow as the Obama administration sits the fence in a bid not to alienate their strategic allies in the Middle East (see Abu Saleh in Yemen, Netanyahu in Israel, the Saudi Monarchy, and currently Mubarak etc.) The following Q&A was truly a gem:
AP Reporter: Do you think Mubarak is a dictator? 
White House Press Secretary: We think Mubarak has the chance to show us who he is by allowing for a peaceful transition in Egypt.
As one Twitter poster pointed out simply:
Coffee_n_Cream RT @noonanjo: If bloodying innocents in the street isn't enough for Obama to drop the "orderly transition" shit, nothing is. #Jan25 #Egypt 
I urge American citizens who care about the people of Egypt to write a letter to the White House or contact your Senator or Representative supporting their bid to establish a democracy and hold transparent elections. If you wish to send an email to the Obama Administration you may do so here. You may also contact the official White House comments line at (+1) 202-456-1111 if you wish to leave a voice message. It's entirely true that your messages will be read and responded to by White House staff, but the point is by flooding the White House with responses to the crisis it will result in a collective opinion being considered. People overseas are also welcome to comment and write in.

31 January 2011

Censorship v. Civil Liberties: Thoughts on Internet Freedom and State Security

News concerning WikiLeaks and Julian Assange has been since drowned out by the events currently unfolding in Egypt. Nonetheless, the two issues are interestingly linked through the actions and views of a group of hackers, or 'hacktivists' if you will, known only as 'Anonymous.'

Internet Freedom Fighters, Anonymous, have recently posted a new video on its website urging global protests according to BBC News. The group of hackers, or 'cyber-warriors' as they would rather be called, gained notoriety by supporting Julian Assange and organizing cyber attacks against companies that caved to US government pressure to deny their services and servers to Wikileaks. The group has become so infamous in its support of Wikileaks that the FBI executed search warrants on 40 Anonymous members and is continuing to the raid the homes of its members based in the United States.

The video on the group's blog declares an admirable mission statement loaded with images of freedom of information protesters wearing V for Vendetta's Guy Fawkes masks. The video states the group's agenda:
"We believe that free speech is non-negotiable, the quality of an idea matters more than its authorship, and the radical notion that information should be free. We are done waiting for someone to save us from tyranny and censorship. The Internet needs champions and we will rise. We didn't start this to destroy a cult, we took on a cult to defend free speech. Tens of thousands strong, we lie in wait as the real battle approaches. We are Anonymous and so are you."
The group has taken on some of the most oppressive governments. During the recent Tunisian uprising, Anonymous spearheaded DDoS (Denial of Service) attacks against Tunisian government websites in reaction to the government's actions to block communication between activists. Tunisian hackers reportedly joined the group to coordinate attacks. The group successfully crippled eight Tunisian government sites. The group's Facebook page calls for action in Egypt in lieu of the communication restrictions against protesters: "My fellow Anonymous, the Egyptian government has taken action against it`s people which negates everything we stand for, there for we have decided to take action in the matter.... Operation Egypt/Operation Sekhmet is at hand... Let us Strike like the wind.... swift, unseen and unstoppable!"

Whether members of Anonymous and WikiLeaks are labeled cyber-warriors or cyber-terrorists depends on which side of the debate you are on. Anonymous, while calling for those who support them to join in the cyber fight, always provides a disclaimer that DDoS attacks are against the law in most countries and one can be held liable for participating in such actions. Having said that, however, Anonymous' fight on behalf of freedom of speech and information in Tunisia and more recently Egypt is praiseworthy. Without doubt, the group is a thorn on the side of any government that wishes to control the flow and framing of information, whether via the Internet or other media such as publications, radio, or TV. In the United States, the issue of WikiLeaks and Anonymous' role in defending the whistle-blowing medium is tacked as a problem of 'national security.'

Civil liberties is a sticky subject when considering the Internet from a democratic government perspective especially in regards the blurry lines between what constitutes a criminal action versus freedom of expression. In dictatorial or oppressive regimes it's much easier to draw the line between the 'good guys' and the 'bad guys.' In countries such as the United States, Britain, or any government which espouses and protects the rights of its people, freedom of information debates enter a legal gray zone. If an information medium is being used to encourage violence, hatred, racism, misogyny or teach people how to build dirty bombs that could essentially be a serious problem. One of the stranger cases on the matter has been the American Civil Liberties Union's (ACLU) defense of NAMBLA (The National Man-Boy Love Association) where American conservatives accused the ACLU of encouraging pedophilia. The ACLU has since issued a statement concerning its defense of freedom of expression for unpopular organisations.

The ACLU stated:
"The principle is as simple as it is central to true freedom of speech: those who do wrong are responsible for what they do; those who speak about it are not. It is easy to defend freedom of speech when the message is something many people find at least reasonable. But the defense of freedom of speech is most critical when the message is one most people find repulsive. That was true when the Nazis marched in Skokie. It remains true today."
Philosophically one could argue that total freedom of information could reasonably be dangerous to society. Are there things people should not know? Is the concept of 'forbidden knowledge' still salient where the Internet proves to be an outlet where one can find literally anything from the high ideals of civil society groups speaking out against dictators and holding forums of political debate to the most degrading items such as criminal child pornography rings or spaces for organized crime to profit through fraud, illegal gambling, or sex trafficking? I certainly don't have the answers to these questions, but there are very good arguments to be made in regards to certain information needing to be regulated or watched by law enforcement if that information results in harming people where the protection of people is a government responsibility.

In the late 18th century, the American Founding Fathers came together and reflected on the moral and ethical questions concerning the foundation of government. They chose to establish a democracy based on values which were formulated during the French Enlightenment with a nod to their own forebears who left 'divine' monarchies for the new world in order to have freedom of religion. They founded a government on the premise that all men, and later women, were equal and endowed with certain inalienable rights. Inalienable rights are what cannot be surrendered by the citizen to the sovereign as defined by Francis Hutcheson in 1725.  The right of private judgment, for example, is inalienable.

Many political philosophers have debated the premises on which American democracy is based. For example, concepts like "freedom" and "rights" and "equality" are entirely taken for granted by the majority of people. Everything human culture and society has come up with historically from the laws and regulations of government to the rituals and practice of religion is the result of collective imagination. This makes any political philosopher at once aware of the fragility of any established order but also of the opportunity to commit great acts of change in societies that people suffered under oppressive circumstances.

American politicians and administration officials eye WikiLeaks and groups such as Anonymous warily. Rep. Ron Paul's defense of WikiLeaks on the House floor this past December calls for common sense. The WikiLeaks controversy may well be less about national security than the fear of certain politicians being made to look bad for talking badly behind each other's backs and for backing failed foreign policies such as supporting certain dictators.

In an eloquent five minute speech before Congress, Rep. Paul provided a heavy dose of common sense in regards to the WikiLeaks controversy and on behalf of freedom of information. He cited significant precedents in U.S. history where those who disseminated leaked information or whistle-blowed against ineffective or amoral foreign policies were hailed as public heroes:
"The New York Times, as a results of a Supreme Court ruling, was not found guilty in 1971 for the publication of the Pentagon Papers. Daniel Ellsberg never served a day in prison for his role in obtaining these secret documents. The Pentagon Papers were also inserted into the Congressional record by Senator Mike Gravel, with no charges of any kind being made of breaking any national security laws. Yet the release of this classified information was considered illegal by many, and those who lied us into the Vietnam war, and argued for its prolongation were outraged. But the truth gained from the Pentagon Papers revealed that lies were told about the Gulf of Tonkin attack. which perpetuated a sad and tragic episode in our history. Just as with the Vietnam War, the Iraq War was based on lies. We were never threatened by weapons of mass destruction or al Qaeda in Iraq, though the attack on Iraq was based on this false information. Any information which challenges the official propaganda for the war in the Middle East is unwelcome by the administration and the supporters of these unnecessary wars."
Groups such as WikiLeaks and Anonymous are not out to destroy Western governments or to purposely threaten the security of people but instead desire to provide a space for political transparency and public accountability. Of course, this is not good for some politicians and those who have credibility to lose as a result of bad foreign policies or embassy badmouthing and these are the one's most staunchly against these groups. WikiLeaks members have been careful to redact any information that could potentially threaten the lives of military sources. Journalists working at bureaus around the world have also taken upon themselves similar ethical responsibilities weighing the consequences of any information they would potentially publish.

The label 'terrorist' has been bandied around without much thought. If we're going to label anyone a 'cyber terrorist' then consider those with actual intent to harm people. Although I sympathize with a government's need to regulate information, especially military intelligence, on the basis of national security, I question the WikiLeaks and Anonymous witch hunts.

Academics Pen An Open Letter to President Obama

Prominent academics from the fields of politics, history, and US foreign policy have come together to write the following open letter to President Barack Obama in support of the protests in Egypt and calling for a revision of U.S. foreign policy more in line with its democratic ideals and values:

http://www.accuracy.org/an-open-letter-to-president-barack-obama/ 

Please repost or 'retweet' this letter! Make some noise.

The Lessons of the Arab Revolutions (or Why Corrupt Dictators Can't Win in the Long Run)

I've always been a believer in karma, the concept that every action has a consequence even if it's not seen immediately, that what goes around comes around. The more I delve into history and observe current events the more I am becoming convinced there's also such thing as political karma and political leaders always reap the consequences of their actions, whether they serve their people well or whether they are self-serving.

The recent revolution in Tunisia which ousted Zine El Abidine Ben Ali and the massive uprising in Egypt against Hosni Mubarak, as well as the protests warming up in Yemen, Jordan, and potentially Syria were all inspired by the sacrifice of a man in despair. Tunisian Mohamed Bouazizi lit himself on fire which became an act of political revolt at the state of his country wracked by rising food prices, unemployment, censorship and political repression. His sacrifice has inspired millions to have the courage to stand up against oppression and corruption resulting in a revolution in Tunisia. Against all odds collective action for social justice was incited by the sacrifice of this man who is an allegory for the despair of all those living under corrupt dictatorships. Bouazizi became a martyr for a greater political cause in the Arab world, one that is far too familiar for those living under regimes similar to Ben Ali's. 

The prerequisites to be a dictator is delusion, a certain dose of megalomania and control issues. These regimes masqueraded as democracies with their de facto dictators censoring, detaining, torturing, or outright murdering their political opposition. Social media, whether newspapers, books, or the Internet remained under varying levels of control from mere restrictions such as censorship to total blackouts. Opposition leaders who escaped with their lives have spent or are currently spending years in exile from their homelands. It is no secret that these strongmen ruled by force and repression. Moreover, through corrupt practices these dictators have stolen millions of state dollars into their own bank accounts, into the coffers of their closest henchmen, and even bought certain loyalties through sheer bribery. 

Unfortunately for the United States, these authoritarian regimes now facing potential ousters have been long-standing strategic allies in the region. While some American politicians and conservative media enjoy pointing a finger at China for supporting corrupt dictators for economic advantage in Africa, perhaps the United States should look to cleaning up their own backyard in regards to the foreign policy status quo in the Middle East. While U.S. policy makers and their PR staff paint our country as the 'beacon of democracy' for the world, American foreign policy-making has been a mixed bag of stumbles, stupidities, and outright hypocrisy since the end of World War II. This is in part a consequence of historical changes at the turn of the century: Wilsonian idealism versus balance of power politics, the ideal of collective security versus national sovereignty and self-determination, and finally, among the academic schools of thought and divisive American party lines, liberalism pitted against realism.   

A student of politics would regard the status quo as the norm. After all, Machiavelli wrote that it's better to be feared than loved and realists would argue that political realities call for political expediency. 'Of course, everyone is essentially greedy and self-serving so it's inevitable all countries will work solely for its own interests and dictators will be self-serving,' quips the cynical realist. No one learns from history, after all, regardless that we are told to. The greatest empires have been destroyed due to their greed, taking for granted their military and economic power and over-stretching it, a belief in invincibility, and willful blindness toward the greater human realities of the people beneath their reigns. The harshest dictators have fallen either by threatening too many outside their borders with aggression or by revolutionary reaction from within against their stifling oppression. Political karma in action.

It's time that the world transcends the divisive camps of liberalism and realism with a more holistic approach to politics and governing: moral realism. Political power should not be construed as a zero-sum game but as a responsibility with certain obligations in wielding it. Political leaders, whether in democracies or not, should cease viewing their role as an elitist right for ego validation but as a position where they must serve and protect the people residing within their borders in the best way possible and foster peace and prosperity for those outside their borders as well if they want national prosperity. 

The best metaphorical analogy for moral realism can be rooted in the ancient Chinese concept of the mandate of heaven, a philosophical concept concerning the legitimacy of rulers: "The Mandate of Heaven postulates that heaven would bless the authority of a just ruler, but would be displeased with a despotic ruler and would withdraw its mandate, leading to the overthrow of that ruler. The Mandate of Heaven would then transfer to those who would rule best." While in today's world we no longer believe in divine right, ideally a political leader's legitimacy should be based on his conduct toward his people, his ability and willingness to serve them and his disposition at being just and wise and balanced in his or her actions.

Whether this concept is applied or not, political karma exists and those who do follow a path of moral realism are far better off than those who truly believe it's better to be feared. In the long-run, corrupt and self-serving dictators can't win. Eventually, they'll reap their political karma. Similarly, nations that support dictators need to reconsider and weigh the consequences of that support because it's a short-term plan for the long-term problem of protecting their own interests. The day politicians realize that the interests, prosperity, and peace of others are in their own interests will be the day the world becomes a better place to live.

In the meantime, the mandate to rule has been withdrawn from the likes of Ben Ali, Mubarak, and all those who believe repression and torture are the order of the day and who, in sheer self-deception and perhaps denial sincerely believe they are supported and loved by millions. In Cairo, one National Democratic Party (NDP) spokesman told an Al Jazeera correspondent amid anti-Mubarak protests:

NDP Spokesman: "Millions of Egyptians want the president to stay." 
Al Jaazeera Correspondent: "Where are they?"

As one friend put succintly, concerning these dictators and their cronies: 'Muppets taking the piss.'

11 December 2010

Rep. Ron Paul (R-Texas) Defends Wikileaks

Rep. Ron Paul gives the House a dose of common sense: