PORTRAIT OF A COFFEE HOUSE: People engage in conversation, for it is there that news is communicated and where those interested in politics criticize the government in all freedom and without being fearful, since the government does not heed what the people say. {Jean Chardin, 17th Century French Traveller}
Showing posts with label Free Media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Free Media. Show all posts

29 September 2011

BBC Panorama: Syria Inside the Secret Revolution

Apologies for being MIA. Have been taking on a few projects these past few weeks and life has been a little hectic. Need to catch up with news and reading!

This BBC report is brought to you via The Revolting Syrian:

30 June 2011

Story Highlights: Arab Revolutions & More

This month's issue of National Geographic has published some pretty fabulous features worth sharing:

Baghdad After the Storm: a former U.S. Army sergeant returns to Baghdad to reflect on how much has changed since the 2003 invasion. Despite the continued hardships and sectarian divisions facing the city's residents development and daily life go on. A mixture of illustrative emotion, flashbacks, and photography.

Middle East Youth Rising - Young, Angry, and Wired: A brief feature with an overview of a budding tech-savvy Arab generation, political and economic dissatisfactions, and revolt. "Some 60 percent of the people in the Middle East are under 30 years old, and many of them are angry. Like young people everywhere, they have ambitions. They want, they need, they crave. They feel constrained—especially, perhaps, when they watch satellite television or surf the Internet. There they can see how the rest of the world lives. Social media (including personal blogs, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and more) allow young men and women to share their frustrations in ways they couldn't in the past."

The Search for Cleopatra: She is infamous because she is illusive. A woman of a thousand faces, National Geographic follows archaelogists on a quest to uncover the real Cleopatra dissecting myth and legend from reality.

And, finally, recent clippings of interest:

Coalition of Factions From the Streets Fuels a New Opposition in Syria: NYT's Anthony Shadid reports on the swiftly changing political landscape in Syria.

'Saudi Arabia is simply a very different society from Egypt, Tunisia or Syria': Why isn't revolution occurring in Saudi Arabia? The Guardian's Jason Burke examines the social and political factors that have kept Saudi citizens from revolting.

Yanar Mohammed—Iraqi Women’s Vigilant Champion: An interview by Marcia G. Yerman of the Women's Media Center of Yanar Mohammed, founder of the Organisation of Women's Freedom in Iraq (OWFI), in lieu of the recent harassment and violence against women's rights protesters in Baghdad's Tahrir Square.

The Birth of 'Free Media' in Eastern Libya: a report in PDF available via Reporters Without Borders.  

05 May 2011

Thrashing Media Freedoms & Arbitrary Arrests: Eye on Syria and Bahrain

The Trump v. Obama bonanza and the recent death of Osama bin Laden (carefully timed to be announced in the middle of The Apprentice) has been drowning out a lot of more important ongoing news. World Press Freedom Day has gone by this May 3rd and, lest we forget, journalists in Syria and Bahrain are facing rough odds. Paris-based Reporters Without Borders issued this year's list of press freedom "predators" this past Tuesday. Who's new to the list this year? The King of Bahrain.

Yesterday, Toby C. Jones published a great piece on the Arab Reform Bulletin, a publication by the Carnegie Endowment for Peace, with an analysis and overview of Bahrain's censorship measures. To name a few, Al Wasat, Bahrain's leading independent paper is expected to close down on May 10 and, according to The Media Line, "the Bahrain Center for Human Rights reported on Tuesday that 68 journalists have been laid-off, arrested and threatened." Even medical personnel and staff are not immune to the repression. The Guardian reported that medics have become targets of retribution simply for helping injured protesters. The Media Line further added that about 50 medics would face military trial for 'subversive acts.'

In Syria, a similar pattern of response against media and opposition supporters has taken place. This past Wednesday, Al Jazeera confirmed that one of its journalists, Dorothy Parvaz, was arrested in Syria. Al Jazeera has launched an online campaign on Twitter with the tag #FreeDorothy as well as a Facebook page. Today, the Neiman Foundation, of which Parvaz is a fellow, has also called for her release. For the past month, arbitrary arrests of journalists and suspected opposition supporters has been the norm in Syria with the addition of violent crackdowns against protesters, especially in Deraa, which some observers are calling a 'massacre.'

If these regimes believe that arbitrary arrests, violent retribution, and thrashing media freedoms will maintain the status quo they really ought to reconsider their tactics. Historically, such actions only result in strengthening the resolve of those who genuinely seek political reform for their countries building up international criticism for the regime and sympathy for the victims of crackdowns. Is there any political sense in detaining journalists, bloggers and medics, shooting at unarmed protesters, and even using torture and blackmail to threaten opposition supporters? Do these tactics ever provide a desired outcome in long-run? While in the private sphere individuals are expected to act with civility towards one another, the same ethics and rules of behavior never apply in the political realm which is a sad sight. If the governments of Syria and Bahrain continue to take "desperate" measures against protesters and media representatives they will surely find themselves committing political suicide.

05 April 2011

Crowd Intelligence: The Case for Supporting a Free Web Globally

In a previous post regarding civil liberties, I mentioned that philosophically one could argue that total freedom of information could reasonably be dangerous to society especially in democracies where lines can be blurred between what constitutes a criminal action versus what is simply freedom of expression (the ambiguous term 'terrorist' being one such issue). Although, I suggested we should look at what actions constitute the intent to actually harm or impede on the rights of others versus actions that promote public accountability of one's government policies.

Currently, in Bahrain where protests are ongoing, the government has violently cracked down on opposition supporters and the media. The Bahrain Human Rights Council claims that 370 people have been arrested since the imposition of the emergency law on March 15. These include bloggers, human rights activists, and journalists. On March 28, the military public prosecutor imposed a media gag, banning "any publishing, through print, audio, video and online media, based on the requirements of discretion and commitment to the principle of confidential investigation." Here we have a government which instead of empowering and serving its people seeks to serve its own selfish interests by suppressing them. This is an unwise policy that is likely to backlash in the long-run. Moral realism and political karma will eventually prevail. No government can succeed or have stability for the long-term without seeking to serve the population on which its legitimacy depends, whether it's a monarchy, an oligarchy, or a democracy.

Consider this, right now the Internet is not a free medium globally. Censorship imposition and information regulation varies in different countries and government monitoring is quite common. I am not against monitoring the web if it is to prevent crime with proper privacy laws in place to protect innocent individuals. However, if monitoring is utilized to root out, blackmail, arrest, or even kill political opposition leaders such technology should not be sold by democratic countries to non-democratic ones. 

A free web benefits everyone politically, socially, and culturally because it empowers individuals. If people globally were to have open access to information, without political censorship, exchange ideas, have public forums of free debate then collectively the Internet becomes a powerful catalyst to transform societies simply by granting individuals the responsibility to verify fact from fiction and to organize collective decision-making in keeping their own governments accountable. Of course this depends on a population that has access to the Internet and who are literate, something that should be encouraged and promoted. Above all, greater civil liberties on the Internet also means inspiring greater creativity in individuals through collective exchange. This has massive impact not merely among artistic and literary groups, but also among corporate, business, and civil society groups who can connect through the Internet. Problems that have gone unresolved through isolated decision-making can benefit by access to crowd intelligence.

In 2004, James Surowiecki published a fascinating book The Wisdom of Crowds. Surowiecki argues that  the aggregation of information in groups results in decisions that are often better made than any single individual in the group. He argues that four elements are necessary for a 'wise crowd': 1. diversity of opinion, 2. independence of opinion (i.e. one's opinion is not influenced by others), 3. decentralization (i.e. people can draw from their unique local knowledge), and 4. aggregation (i.e. mechanisms are in place to turn private judgments into a collective decision). 

In corporate cultures, even among NGOs and in government departments, decision-making can be easily isolated, 'cliquefied', and threatened by the possibility of group-think. Surowiecki addresses the cases where crowd intelligence has failed: where opinions in a group are homogenous rather than diverse, where hierarchies are too strict, where groups are protective of their 'turf' or specialization and don't allow outsiders to contribute, where decisions are imitated, and where emotionalism or herd instinct can take hold. 

Now consider the massive resource potential of collective intelligence the Internet provides if it were a free medium globally. People across the world could easily provide for at least three of Surowieki's conditions for a 'wise crowd.' Already, mediums such as Wikipedia and Twitter allow people to cross reference information, cite sources, share news and opinion, and debate dubious points. Twitter and Facebook have been cited as factors helping aid the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia. Although their influence has been questioned in regards to the current Arab revolutions taking place, one can't underestimate them as powerful tools or organization or to rally public opinion among a younger generation of net users.

Governments do themselves a disservice through the imposition of censorship and fail to tap a significant resource when they limit forums of information exchange. What if these online crowds were properly utilized to resolve major political, social, and economic problems globally instead of relying solely on 'experts'? The possibilities the Internet provides for this is endless. A politically uncensored Internet globally could well transcend language barriers and provide for collective creativity and problem-solving as well as for social, cultural, and political transformation. 

31 March 2011

Threatened, Missing or Arrested Bloggers: Submit a Report

Global Voices Advocacy hosts a page keeping track of the status of bloggers around the world who have gone missing or have been arrested and follows-up on them. Their project, Threatened Voices, tracks the suppression of online free speech.

Lend your support to these bloggers here. If you have any information on their whereabouts and status please contact the Threatened Voices project by either leaving a comment on the specific blogger's page or submitting a report regarding any bloggers you know who have been threatened, gone missing, or have been arrested or whether they have been released.

30 March 2011

Who Profits from Censorship? Timothy Karr Tells All

Back in 2004, when I was still a student at a private university in Washington, I was appalled to discover that the company who regulated my university networks, Cisco, also sold products that allowed the Chinese government to censor websites and regulate information access. Cisco is not the only company profiting from authoritarian regimes. Timothy Karr, the campaign director for Save The Internet as well as a contributer to The Huffington Post, has written extensively on US companies aiding and abetting censorship overseas. One of his recent reports, "Censorship: Made In the USA" is a damning indictment of American companies supporting the crackdown of Arab bloggers and newsreaders simply by doing business with regimes not particularly for civil liberties.

Karr cites a new report published by the OpenNet Initiative, an NGO advocating for an Open Internet. The report lists several US companies who have sold technologies that red list or block access to websites to oppressive governments. These include the popular McAffee, Inc., Websence, Inc., and Palo Alto Network.  Previously, Karr had published a story concerning another US company, Narus, "which sold to Egypt and Libya an Internet spying technology that lets state security forces track online and cellphone communications and even target the speaker's whereabouts for arrest." This story kicked off an investigation by the House Foreign Relations Committee and the State Department. Karr writes that the results of these investigations are still pending.

According to Karr, Rep. Bill Keating (MA) is the only voice on Capital Hill promising to propose legislation that would prevent US companies from selling censorship technology. Karr has posted a link to a petition to both Rep. Keating and Sen. Dick Durbin (IL) to get this legislation moving forward. Of course, despite citizen action I have my reservations that these measures will succeed. One could say, the United States has a political interest in promoting free media, but on the other hand it depends.

This is not the first time American companies have committed abuses overseas where the interests of capitalism take precedence over liberal ideals. The logic these companies operate on is that simply because they sold the perpetrators the tools of the crime leaves them innocent of the crime because they're just doing business and are not responsible for the purposes for which their products are used. This logic is flawed because in the long-run these companies will suffer 'moral costs' of their amoral investments. Here moral realism can be applied: public opinion will ultimately tarnish the reputation of these companies and when the political status quo is overturned in countries where oppression has been the norm (as currently seen in the Middle East) they will lose their business. Companies can't continue doing business this way and profit in the long-term without considering the people they're exploiting and how that will effect their markets and image in the future. It's simply bad business. Short-term profits won't compensate for long-term losses.

On the bright side, however, some American companies understand the concept above and have taken steps to do business by promoting civil liberties. In 2009, Google faced-off with China over censorship barriers and had its license to operate in China revoked. Google has since renewed its license with China without making concessions to censorship. Moreover, Google is crafting and seeking influence Internet policy by supporting an open and free Internet. If other US companies followed Google's business model, conducting their business practices to empower people with their services and products instead of repressing them, they would be creating greater opportunity and profiting themselves by the very act of profiting others.

Update: A really fascinating story on Google just came out in which the Internet giant is investing $1 million on Internet censorship detection technologies. Go Google!!!

________________________

Timothy Karr also runs a popular blog, MediaCitizen (http://mediacitizen.blogspot.com/), covering issues as far ranging as criticism of media policy, censorship, analysis on old media and new media.